Skip to main content

God the Omnipotent and Stupid?

One of the questions you will often hear raised about God goes along the lines, "If there is an omnipotent God why doesn't he do X?", where X may be anything from stopping wars or preventing earthquakes to curing cancer.

Often there is a deeply personal reason behind the question, which makes a purely rational answer wholly unsatisfying. All the same, it's a rational question and some kind of rational answer is deserved. But two things make it a complex question to which no simple answer is possible.

One is the extraordinary diversity of the things that 'X' may represent, all of them having different causes with different and completely unrelated solutions.

The other is the sole focus on God's omnipotence. Because God, if he exists, must be so much more than just that.

There is an old philosophical conundrum on the same subject, of the kind that philosphers love to pose and to ponder. If God is omnipotent, can he create an object so massive that he himself cannot move it?

Posed purely in terms of omnipotence, the question seems unanswerable - although it does beg the question: what exactly do you mean by 'omnipotent'? But God, as most people and most religions would understand him, is much more than just omnipotent. He is also wise, and he is always true to himself. Omnipotence might, perhaps, enable him to create an infinitely massive object for no other reason than vanity. But wisdom would surely prevent him from doing something so unspeakably daft!

In short - God may be omnipotent, but he is not stupid.

Life and our own experience teaches us that, just because you can do something, that doesn't mean it's wise. The tale of Pandora's box has been acted out many times in human history, most recently in the invention of the atomic bomb. Some things cannot be undone, and are best never done. Even things intended for good can turn out bad. The obvious course is often not the wisest. 

Our world is a wonderful, complex and finely balanced system which, if interfered with, can bite back unexpectedly - as climate change is showing us. If God were to step in and magically solve all our 'X's, who knows what the unintended consequences would be? 

That's not an answer to every question about 'X'. But it does suggest that the question is a lot more complicated than it seems.

It does also beg the question, why did God create such a world? Could he not have made it differently? But that's a question for next time.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Robbing The Poor To Feed The Rich?

Now that cuts in spending seem to be on the agenda of all the main political parties, the big questions still to be answered are: how much? And where will the axe fall? According to a recent poll by Ipsos MORI, published by the BBC ( http://bit.ly/d168R ), the most popular candidate with most people is overseas aid. That’s not really surprising. It’s understandable that during severe financial crisis most people want our government to look after our own affairs first. Charity, as the saying goes, begins at home. But is it really right for the poorest nations of the world to be penalised for a crisis that was brought on by the rich? The developing world already spends $1.3 on debt repayment for every $1 it receives in grants (Source: World Centric, http://bit.ly/b5C7f ). Every day at least $100 million flows from the poor of the world into the pockets of the rich. Existing problems like drought and famine will not go away just because there is a worldwide recession, and the poor are mo...
2 comments
Read more

A God Who Reaches Out

Years ago I was guest speaker at a conference of a group of churches in a remote part of SW Uganda. One of the delegates I met there had walked for a couple of days to attend, sleeping out in the bush under the stars, and drinking water from whatever muddy pool he came across. I've been back several times since, but I've never forgotten the remarkable dedication of that one individual. It's been widely acknowledged, and I've written here previously, that the universe seems to speak to us of an architect - a creator of everything we see around us. If that's true, it would require similar dedication on their part for us to have any chance of knowing and understanding them. The innumerable religions and concepts of God that we find around the world today, not to mention throughout history, and the many other theories of origins, are testimony to this. Left to ourselves we are incapable of figuring out definitively, to everyone's agreement and satisfaction, who or w...
Post a Comment
Read more

Strongholds and Roots

 Autumn is a time when most plants abandon life above ground in preparation for the hardships of the Winter. The branches of most trees and shrubs drop their leaves and go into a dormant state. Herbaceous plants die back to ground level. For them life simply continues below ground where the Winter frost cannot reach. They quite literally go back to their roots. In the Bible there is an old proverb that says:     The wicked desire the stronghold of evildoers,         but the root of the righteous endures.         (Proverbs 12: 12) Very few people enjoy living with insecurity - most of us want the safety a stronghold. It might be in a good job, underpinned with qualifications, skills and experience. Perhaps in family or a circle of close friends. Sometimes it's in self-protection - playing all our cards close to our chest and never making ourselves vulnerable. Strongholds are not necessarily evil, but they have one thing in common. So...
Post a Comment
Read more